by Myra Malhotra (’26) | October 6, 2023
Disney, a global entertainment giant, has a history of creating cinematic classics cherished by generations. Currently, the company is at the forefront of the trend of reimagining beloved animated movies through live-action adaptations. One of the most highly anticipated remakes is Snow White; however, the new release of this film has brought to light both the merits and controversies surrounding Disney’s live-action trend.
Originally announced in October 2016, the makers of Snow White initially kept details about the cast and storyline under wraps. However, as production progressed, the casting of Rachel Zegler as Snow White shocked fans. Some criticized Disney for prioritizing diversity over the original storyline, casting a Colombian and Polish actress as a character of German origin. Another controversy over Disney’s casting choices involved its failure to cast little people in the film to portray the seven dwarves. This decision led to accusations of bias against individuals with dwarfism and missed opportunities for these actors to showcase their talent.
Prior to the forthcoming Snow White live-action, Disney has received both praise and disapproval for its adaptations of classic tales such as The Lion King, Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast, and The Little Mermaid. The Lion King faced criticism for its perceived lack of creativity and the limited expressiveness of its animated animals. In contrast, Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin were box office successes, winning fans over for enriching the original story without sacrificing cherished nostalgia. While initial backlash emerged with the casting of a black actress as Ariel in The Little Mermaid, the film’s success somewhat eased tensions.
One significant deviation in the Snow White remake lies in its marketing strategy, largely due to contentious remarks made by lead actress Rachel Zegler. Her comments, including “it’s no longer 1937” and her portrayal of Snow White as an independent woman rather than a love interest, drew public backlash. Many thought her promotional approach was disastrous, because of her mocking remarks about the original Snow White. While Zegler’s sentiments were not entirely new, they seemed to undermine Snow White’s essence, emphasizing the departure from the princess’s traditional focus on “true love” to a character with a “girl boss” archetype.
Amidst the passionate discussions, it is essential to acknowledge the inherent challenges Disney faces in striking a balance between honoring beloved classics and infusing them with fresh perspectives. Disney’s commitment to diversity and adaptability during changing times is still commendable, despite the backlash.Disney’s dedication to live-action adaptations persists, with plans for Moana and The Hunchback of Notre Dame following Snow White. These upcoming projects may encounter similar public resistance, and Disney would certainly benefit from reflecting on previous situations as they continue forward.
