Skip to Content

Food For Thought: how grocery stores are the battleground for economics and nutrition

Dominic So ('27) shopping in a grocery store aisle.
Dominic So (’27) shopping in a grocery store aisle.
Timothy Cho (’25)

Picture this: It’s the end of the week, and you have to restock on a few essentials. You head to the grocery store with just a few items in mind: milk, eggs, and vegetables. But, as you roll up to the cashier, you’re stunned to see your cart overflowing with items you hadn’t planned on purchasing. Ever wonder why this happens? It’s not just about temptation; you’re actually being subtly guided, like a pawn in an orchestrated game. Supermarkets are meticulously designed to influence your decisions, using subtle psychological tricks to steer you toward spending more than you planned, often without you even realizing. Once you do, you’ll start to see how every section, every shelf, and every step in the shopping process is a part of a greater strategy to influence your spending habits. 

Meet the “nudge theory,” a marketer’s best friend. The nudge theory helps shape your choices even before you enter a store. Popularized by behavioral economists Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein, the nudge theory suggests that small changes in how choices are presented, or these “nudges,” can significantly influence a shopper’s behavior without taking away their freedom to choose. Supermarkets harness this theory to maximize their profits. But how exactly does this play out?

The theory starts with the layout of the entire store. As you enter, you’re typically greeted by the vibrant colors and fresh scents of flowers and produce. This welcoming atmosphere puts you in a positive mood, making you more inclined to spend your money. Inside, essentials like milk and bread are often placed at opposite ends of the store. This strategic placement forces you to go through multiple aisles filled with additional items, increasing the chances of you picking up extra products you didn’t initially plan on buying.

Specifically within the aisles, supermarkets use calculated product placement on shelves to guide what ends up in your cart. A key tactic is positioning items at eye level or just below it. Research has shown that products at eye level, or slightly below, naturally attract more attention. This is actually proven by the mascot designs on cereal boxes. For instance, children’s cereals often feature mascots that look down, making them appear at kids’ eye level and drawing their attention. In contrast, mascots on cereals aimed at adults are positioned to look straight ahead or slightly upward, aligning with adult eye levels. Another aspect of shelf placement is the strategic use of end-of-aisle displays, which catch your eye as you walk by the aisles. Both of these high-visibility spots are the most valuable for brands that are willing to pay more for premium shelf space. 

The overall sensory environment of a grocery store also plays a significant role in your shopping behavior. Background music, for example, can create a more relaxed atmosphere, making you more likely to spend a longer time in the store, and consequently, buy more. Additionally, larger shopping carts can encourage you to fill them up, with some studies showing that consumer spending with larger carts is over 40% greater than small carts.

As you near the end of your shopping journey, timing and checkout processes continue to further impact your spending. Research indicates that after around 23 minutes of shopping, consumers will start making decisions based more on emotions than on rational thought, leading to more impulsive purchases. Stores take advantage of this at the checkout, where they place tempting, high-profit items, such as candy bars and chocolates, that are easily accessible and hard to resist. 

Overall, these sales tactics aim to get you to buy more and boost the supermarket’s profits. However, buying more doesn’t always benefit you, especially when the items that are most tempting are frequently not the healthiest options. These sales strategies combined with the specific placement of products and the overall grocery store environment, can make it challenging to resist or consider the nutritional value of what you are purchasing. The strategic placement and marketing of these items may be carefully crafted to appeal to you, but their primary purpose is to benefit the retailer – not your health. 

So, how can we navigate these subtle influences as shoppers? The first step is to become aware of these tactics and how they affect our decisions. Planning your shopping trip with a detailed list can help you avoid unnecessary detours and reduce the impact of in-store temptations. When choosing items, focus on the nutritional value of foods. Remember that every product placement and display is a nudge, subtly steering you toward spending more. By staying aware of these cues and planning ahead, you can navigate the supermarket more mindfully and make informed decisions about products.



More to Discover